Lumber vs Papertrail and Better Stack

Papertrail and Better Stack receive your logs as text and search them on their servers, which is what lets them query large volumes quickly. Lumber encrypts each log on your server before it's sent, so its servers can't read it, and your logs are read on your own devices instead. That one difference runs through every row below.

Who Can Read Your LogsLumberOnly the people you give access. Lumber's servers hold ciphertext and no key to it. SecurityPapertrailPapertrail, which receives your logs as text to store and search them.Better StackBetter Stack, which receives your logs as text to store and query them.
EncryptionLumberAES-256-GCM on your server before each log is sent, with a key Lumber doesn't have, then HTTPS on the way. EncryptionPapertrailLogs can be sent as TLS-encrypted syslog. TLSBetter StackTLS in transit and AES-256 at rest, according to its security page. Security
Text SearchLumberOn your device: the app and the lumber command decrypt your logs and search them there. Lumber's servers only narrow by app, level and time. Finding LogsPapertrailOn Papertrail's servers, with saved searches and search alerts. PlansBetter StackOn Better Stack's servers, with a query builder and SQL. Pricing
AI AgentsLumberThe lumber command's MCP server runs on your computer and decrypts there. It's in the official MCP Registry. AI AgentsPapertrailIts search API, which searches on Papertrail's servers. Search APIBetter StackA hosted MCP server that runs SQL queries on Better Stack's servers. MCP Server
AppsLumberFor iPhone, iPad, Mac, Windows and Linux, decrypting on the device. DownloadPapertrailA web log viewer. PlansBetter StackA web dashboard, and mobile apps for on-call alerts and incidents. Mobile Apps
PricingLumberBy the number of logs: each plan includes so many a month, and Hobby is free. PricingPapertrailBy volume, per GB a month. PlansBetter StackBy volume, per GB ingested and per GB retained a month. Pricing

Papertrail's and Better Stack's details come from their own pages, checked on November 13, 2026. Their features and prices change, so follow the links for current ones.

Using Papertrail today? See what replaces each way you send it logs, how its systems, alerts and archives map to Lumber, and how to run both while you switch. Moving from Papertrail

What Lumber Doesn't Do

A service that can't read your logs gives up what reading them makes possible. Know these before you switch.

No Search at Scale

There are no queries, dashboards or charts on the server. Text search reads back through your logs on your device, up to 20,000 at a time in the lumber command: enough to find what broke, not to analyze millions of lines.

Finding Logs

No Alerts on Text

Push alerts fire on a log's level, the one part of it Lumber's servers can read. They can't match the words in a message.

No Syslog

Logs come from Lumber's clients or its HTTP API, which encrypt them first, so there's nowhere to point syslog or a log shipper.

Priced per Log

Plans count logs, not bytes, so many short lines use up a plan faster than they'd fill one priced per GB.

Pricing

Servers Only

The clients are for servers you run. An API key carries its app's encryption key, so it can't go in a phone app, web page or game you ship. Those can send their logs through your server.

Logging from Apps You Ship

No Key Recovery

If nobody with access still has an app's key, its logs can't be decrypted, by you or by Lumber.

Losing the Key

Which Fits

Lumber Fits When

  • Your logs carry personal, health or payment data that no outside service should be able to read
  • You find problems by app, level, time and text, on your phone or computer
  • You want an AI agent to read your production logs without your log service reading them too

Papertrail or Better Stack Fits When

  • You search or chart large volumes of logs on the server
  • You collect system logs over syslog or with a log shipper
  • You alert on what a log says, not only its level